From Diogenes to Populist Punk: The Price of Refusal in a Cancel-Culture Age

What does it mean, in 2025, for a musician to refuse? To pull back, to withhold, to stand in opposition not just to commerce or to trends, but to the very expectations of audience, industry and society? The art of refusal is not mere contrarianism. It’s a conscious withdrawal, a refusal to participate under certain terms. In the age of streaming, algorithmic playlists, cancel culture and social media metrics, refusal becomes one of the few tools left to artists who still wish to maintain integrity—or at least a sense of autonomy. But is it still possible to refuse and survive? And what does refusal look like across history and genres? In this piece I’ll trace a lineage of rebellion: from Diogenes the Cynic and the Dadaists, through the shock tactics of glam rock or heavy metal, to contemporary bands such as Pussy Riot, Bob Vylan, IDLES and others. I’ll argue that the capacity to refuse is now so constrained by commercial pressures that “refusal” is either sanitised or punished, and that many artists no longer dare risk being social pariahs. The Cynic’s defiance: Diogenes as proto-punk Diogenes of Sinope is, in many respects, the archetypal figure of radical refusal. Living […] The post From Diogenes to Populist Punk: The Price of Refusal in a Cancel-Culture Age appeared first on A&R Factory.

Musventurenal

0 9

What does it mean, in 2025, for a musician to refuse? To pull back, to withhold, to stand in opposition not just to commerce or to trends, but to the very expectations of audience, industry and society? The art of refusal is not mere contrarianism. It’s a conscious withdrawal, a refusal to participate under certain terms. In the age of streaming, algorithmic playlists, cancel culture and social media metrics, refusal becomes one of the few tools left to artists who still wish to maintain integrity—or at least a sense of autonomy. But is it still possible to refuse and survive? And what does refusal look like across history and genres? In this piece I’ll trace a lineage of rebellion: from Diogenes the Cynic and the Dadaists, through the shock tactics of glam rock or heavy metal, to contemporary bands such as Pussy Riot, Bob Vylan, IDLES and others. I’ll argue that the capacity to refuse is now so constrained by commercial pressures that “refusal” is either sanitised or punished, and that many artists no longer dare risk being social pariahs. The Cynic’s defiance: Diogenes as proto-punk Diogenes of Sinope is, in many respects, the archetypal figure of radical refusal. Living […]

The post From Diogenes to Populist Punk: The Price of Refusal in a Cancel-Culture Age appeared first on A&R Factory.